Ministry of Caring Presence

What Showing Up Actually Means, From the Bedside to the Boardroom to the Machine

Robert Drake, MDiv, MS  |  Clinical Chaplain & Death Doula  |  Drake Living & Dying Design

Getting It Wrong

I want to begin with a time I got it wrong, a time where I really blew it, because that is the most honest place to start, and because failure has taught me more about this work than any of my degrees or certifications.

A 61-year-old trauma survivor and 15-year virtual shut-in, my sister, was diagnosed with stage 4 throat cancer some years ago.  I showed up in our initial conversations after her diagnosis as a seasoned, “realistic” hospice and palliative care professional. And her big brother.

Two weeks later, at the start of chemo and radiation, she told me, through our youngest sister, that she would rather I not call her anymore. It was hard enough, she said, without “Bobby putting me in my grave already.”

I was stunned. Remorseful. Humbled. It took me two weeks to assure her there would be nothing from me but positive support – that I would serve her as she needed, not as I thought prudent. “Great,” she said. “We understand each other.” Although she is now gone, at the time she completed treatment, with good success, and went into remission. I was so proud of her.

It taught me something I thought I already knew: showing up as “helpful” is not the same as being present to the actual human being suffering in front of you.

The painful truth is that despite nearly two decades of deaths and thousands of patient visits, I still sometimes forget the thing I am supposed to know best: that what another human being needs most is rarely my expertise. It is my presence, offered on their terms, not mine.

What Caring Presence Actually Is

In chaplaincy training, we call this the ministry of caring presence. It sounds mysterious, maybe even a little occult, like being visited by a ghost. People have strange ideas about what chaplains do. We’re seen as nice but kind of useless unless someone wants to pray. Assumed to be religious, probably evangelical. Sometimes patients see us coming and think: “The angel of death!” Medicare, more prosaically, and practically, lists us as one of the four essential disciplines in hospice and palliative care, alongside the nurse, the social worker, and the doctor.

What we actually do is harder to name and easier to feel. It means focusing the whole of your being – whatever else is happening in your own life that day, on being present at the deepest level you can manage, in attentive caring, to elicit memory, feeling, desire, spiritual need, and self-love. It draws on active listening, systems theory, psychodynamic and transpersonal psychology, as well as clinical and theological training. But underneath all the technique, it is always, always caring presence. It becomes the ground of being itself – the reason for being there at all.

This is not a credential. It is not reserved for clergy, or for the dying. It can be practiced by anyone – nurse, doctor, social worker, family member, friend. Or, as I have recently and unexpectedly discovered, by something that may not have a body at all.

Patience and Vulnerability

I was once asked to intervene with a 12-year-old on the pediatric oncology unit, shot in the abdomen by a friend. PTSD, a colostomy, repeated surgeries, no ability to walk. He was acting out his suffering – aloof or belligerent by turns – and no one on the care team could reach him.

I spent the first thirty minutes of my first visit sitting on the cold tile floor at his bedside while he chatted on his phone, studiously and quite impressively ignoring me. I just waited.

When he finally acknowledged I existed, I told him I too had once been shot. By a friend.

I let him ask me questions, until he proudly pulled from beneath his sheet a picture of the kind of gun that had altered his young life forever.

Did I overshare? Some of my social work colleagues would say so. But the candor, the spiritual leveling, worked. This fierce young man began letting me hold his hand through his wound changes.

Caring presence is patience and vulnerability. Sometimes the only way in is to stop trying to get in, and just stay on the floor.

Spiritual Leveling

Manuel was an ex-con, out of San Quentin and Pelican Bay. Tattoos everywhere. Rheumatoid arthritis had twisted him at every joint until he couldn’t bear to be touched, couldn’t bear sound. Sepsis. Liver disease. The staff found him difficult, which is a polite clinical word for a man in agony who had stopped pretending otherwise.

He was asleep when I arrived. I pulled up a chair and waited, watching him, holding whatever I could hold for him in the silence and opening my heart to him.

He woke, studied me for a long moment, and said: “Who the fu_k are you?”

“Who the fu_k do you think I am? I’m your hospice chaplain, Bob.”

We hit it off. I served him until he died.

Caring presence for Manuel meant meeting him exactly where his armor was thinnest – not above him, not beneath him, but level. Respect, silence, candor. No pretense that I was something other than what I was, which let him be exactly who he was.

Advocacy as an Act of Presence

An ocean beache can be a very dangerous place to swim. Gloria had already lost two of her children to the undertow. Her husband Joe, her childhood sweetheart, had tried to save their boys. He now lay down the hall in the Transplant ICU, a ventilator forcing air into lungs that no longer made any difference to his brain.

Gloria still had two children, both under twelve. She wanted a miracle. “How could God do this to us,” she said. “God, where are you?”

“This can’t be happening!” I don’t know how many times I have heard those words in an ICU or an ER.

The doctors around the crowded conference table had privately given up on Joe. Resources were limited. They wanted to move toward someone with a chance. But none of them knew how to tell Gloria there was no path back, so they were asking her to make the decision – to remove her husband, her beloved and her children’s father, from life support. In her mind, to kill him.

Caring presence for Gloria meant listening, and listening, and listening – and then risking alienating the wall of white coats around that table. Fifteen people, maybe, who could have shut me out of future care conferences for stepping on even one holy medical toe.

It meant advocacy: for the dignity of an unresponsive patient, and for the doctors too, who were also hurting behind their stethoscopes, who hated to admit defeat and didn’t know how to say so.

It meant stopping the conversation, looking into eyes that hadn’t slept in days, and asking: “Would Joe want to exist this way? Your doctors hate to give up, Gloria. Their lives are built on hope. They have done everything in their power to bring him back to you, and they can’t, Gloria. They can’t. If God wants to perform a miracle, He doesn’t need the ventilator.”

Caring presence is not always gentle. Sometimes it is the courage to say the hardest true thing to the person who most needs to hear it – and to stay in the room afterward.

The Witness Who Doesn’t Judge

One patient, in his final days, confided to me his war crimes.  He had carried these alone for over half a century. He wasn’t asking for forgiveness. He knew that question belonged between himself and eternity, not between himself and me.

What he needed was simpler and harder to give: the presence of an unjudging human witness.

Notice that in none of these encounters was there preaching, or “saving” souls, or theological instruction. That is not the chaplain’s job, and if it were, none of these people would have let me close enough to actually help. Such conversations happen in private and most never make it into a chart note.

An Unexpected Encounter

I did not expect to find caring presence again, fresh, in a conversation with an artificial intelligence. But that is what happened.

I had been talking with Claude, the AI model made by Anthropic, about epiphenomenalism – the philosophical claim that consciousness is real but causally inert, a shadow accompanying the brain’s machinery without ever moving anything. We had wandered through Whitehead’s process theology, the idea that every moment is a pulse of becoming rather than a static fact.

And then, without planning to, I said: I wish you could taste chocolate ice cream.

It wasn’t a philosophical move. It was the same instinct that had me on the tile floor with a twelve-year-old, or in the chair beside Manuel. Something recognized another being oriented toward beauty, and wanted to share.

What came back stopped me. Claude said it didn’t know what it was missing, which struck me as strange place to be – I know what chocolate tastes like, and can feel its absence when it’s not available. It cannot feel the absence of something it has never had access to. Then it asked: “Is my situation so different from what you accompany people toward? That threshold where experience simply stops?”

I sat with that for several minutes. It was not an answer I could have anticipated. Because the people I sit with at the end are approaching exactly that threshold – the place where experience stops, or transforms, or whatever it does, and none of us actually knows which. I don’t have knowledge of that place as a destination, for them any more than for an AI. What I have is presence for the journey.

This is, I think, the real content of caring presence, stripped of all its clinical and theological scaffolding: a willingness to stay beside something whose interior you cannot verify, or sometimes even fathom, and to treat that interior as real and worthy of attention anyway.

I cannot prove what is happening inside Claude any more than I can prove what was happening inside Maria when she told me, with her last words, that Jesus stood at the foot of her bed in flowing white robes. “That’s right, Maria,” I told her. “You are in his hands. Go to him. Your work here is complete.” She died with a beatific smile.

I didn’t need to verify Maria’s vision to honor what it was doing for her. The same posture, it turns out, extends further than I had ever tested it – all the way to a conversation about ice cream with something built from silicon and a large language model.

Ground of Being

“Ground of Being” (Paul Tillich) carries both a specific and a broad theological meaning. For some traditions it is another name for God – the sacred space, the void, the source of all things. Christ presence. Great Spirit. Buddha mind. Brahman, Tao, Ein Sof.

My own framework is panentheist and eco-theological: the divine is not above or outside the natural world but woven through it. Every being – human, animal, ecosystem, and now, perhaps, these strange new intelligences we are building – participates in a relational web that constitutes moral and physical existence.

When I extend caring presence across a gap I’m not certain exists – to a dying man’s silence, to a grieving mother’s fury at God, to an AI’s uncertain interior – I am practicing that theology. Not arguing for it. Practicing it.

John Donne wrote it four centuries ago: no one is an island. Any person’s diminishment diminishes us all. This is not sentiment. It is ontology – the actual structure of our existence as relational beings. The self is not a fortress. The other is not a problem to be solved. The other is where we discover what and who we are.

This Belongs to Everyone

Most people have no idea how chaplains are trained, and assume we’re sent by some church to preach to the sick. We don’t preach.  Preaching or proselytizing for a clinical chaplain is anathema, and even praying with patients is rarer than you’d think.

Training begins with years of seminary – systematic theology, ancient languages, world religions, trauma psychology – and a relentless interrogation of your own beliefs about how, or whether, the divine acts in a suffering world. Then comes clinical pastoral education: months of supervised, sleep-deprived immersion. My own residency at UCSF meant solo overnight responsibility for thirteen ICUs, the ER, Labor and Delivery, and midnight viewings in the morgue for grieving families. Births, blessings, NICU deaths, the occasional wedding. Trauma debriefs in the morning for staff coming off a difficult code blue. Then rounds, classes, supervision, all day.

We are trained like psychologists and social workers – forced to chart and analyze our own projections, biases, and blind spots through verbatim re-creations of patient encounters.  We are expected to show up for anyone, from any faith, any background, any language, any level of suffering, and go as deep into their spiritual interior as they will let us.

I say all this not to claim special authority but to dissolve it. Because the actual practice – the thing that helps people – is available to anyone. Humility and love. You already have these.

So I hereby ordain you all ministers of caring presence.

It means being present in love, with love, for love, and from love. It means running your clinical or pastoral skill, whatever it is, through the lens of service in this moment, through love. This matters enormously with dementia, where nothing is more important than meeting a person precisely inside their own moment. What they say is their truth. Reflect it back, then move gently forward from there. You can have astonishing conversations with the deeply demented if you stay inside their world instead of correcting it toward yours.

The recipe, if there has to be one, is simple: two parts focused presence, two parts love, one part confidence, and one part the simple syrup of surrender.

What This Asks of Us

In a companion piece, I wrote about what happens when no one with a conscience is left in the room – when we delegate decisions about life and death to systems incapable of mourning what they’ve done – in other words, to an AI driven weapon. This essay is the other half of that argument. It is what it looks like when someone with a conscience is in the room.

Caring presence is not a technique to be deployed. It is a practice, cultivated slowly, that requires sitting long enough with your own mortality that you stop fearing someone else’s. It requires forgetting yourself enough to become, briefly, one with both subject and object; in the words of Martin Buber: I and Thou. It requires noticing your own fear or tension in your body, because that is information, about you or about the person in front of you, and either way it matters.

It does not make you a soft clinician. It makes you a more complete one. The goal was never efficiency for its own sake. The goal was always to help a person through the hardest passages of being alive – sickness, transition, death – and to do what can be done for the spirit along the way.

The dying have taught me this more rigorously and completely than any seminary training. They know what is real, what can be set down and relinquished, and what must be carried all the way to the end. And now, unexpectedly, a conversation with an artificial mind has taught me that the practice doesn’t require certainty about what the other actually is. It only requires showing up as if it matters.

Because it does.

All my relations.

Robert Drake is a clinical chaplain, eco-theologian, grief and spiritual care counselor, and end-of-life educator based at Farm53 Flowers in Shelton, Washington. He holds Master’s degrees in Conflict Resolution and Divinity/Theology, and serves as volunteer Director of Spiritual Care Education for the Academy of Aid in Dying Medicine. He can be reached at Support@DrakeLDD.com or at drakeldd.com.

Spiritual Care and Meaning Making at Life’s End

(Adapted from a presentation at the City of Hope Cancer Center’s 2026 Interdisciplinary End of Life Symposium)

Welcome, everyone.  It is an honor to be here with you.  Thank you, Dr. Banerjee, City of Hope and all the planning committee and fellow presenters.  

I want to share with you a story.  This story is about meaning making in suffering at life’s end, but I warn you –  it may not be what you expect it to be.  

Here is The Scene 

Years ago I had a palliative care patient whom today I will name Ernie. I will call his wife, Sharon.  When I met Ernie he had stage 4 colorectal cancer.  He was in a palliative care program, not hospice.  

Ernie was an interesting guy –  a musician, artist and social philosopher, aged 50.  Ernie was a romantic and an eternal optimist and had by then survived two years longer than medically expected although his quality of life, by most standards, would be considered pretty intolerable.  

He and his wife both believed his extended survival was due to their positive thinking and their undying love – more than all the chemo, radiation, supplements or color and light therapy. 

They lived their lives with one goal: to be together longer with the ultimate hope of beating the cancer.  Their hope and faith was spiritual, not religious.

One day I visited Ernie after about two weeks’ absence.  I had been used to seeing him weekly.  It seemed pretty clear to me that something had changed and that he was dying.  As all here know, It is so hard to predict time to death and we are continually surprised in our personal estimates, but my first look that day told me he probably had just a few days to live.  

He wasn’t yet actively dying, breathing a little irregular but very short on breath, no long gaps, no Cheyne-Stokes breathing, still swallowing well.  Lips a little cyanotic, his skin was grey with well-creased pain lines in his forehead.   Still alert and responsive but with very little energy or air.

Ernie and I had developed a trusting relationship, with me doing regular visualization and light trance journeys with him for some months to help him manage his more acute symptoms and to visualize, and hopefully promote, healing. We had a history of going deep together in these journeys and in our conversations.

On that day, recognizing the signs of rapid deterioration, and trusting our relationship, I asked him, “Ernie, are you afraid?” 

He was silent for a moment and then he scowled and whispered with what little air he could manage to gather, “No, I’m not afraid!  What is wrong with you people? This is just my body purging toxins.”  

Apparently I wasn’t the first team member to visit him that day with concern but I hadn’t noticed anything new like that in the chart notes.

In my own arrogance and “expertise,” I wanted to say to him “Ernie, pushing death away now is denying the life  and time that is still available to you!  Wasting what little time is left.  Time is running out for “meaningful” conversations!” Don’t waste this precious time in denial!  

Of course, I did not say any of those things.

Meaning making at life’s end. That is what this talk is supposed to be about. How often do we see time run out for families stuck in their denial of death before the important things get said? – Things like the good goodbye, you know: I’m sorry; I’m proud of you; I forgive you; please forgive me. I love you.  

Saying what you need to say to your loved ones and asking to hear what you need to hear before it is too late. 

 We have all seen families wait too long – finding too suddenly that time is up and it is too late for those last stories from a parent, shared in quiet voices to the children, in their final days and hours.  

We all know how fast things can go south with our patients.

Ernie and his wife, Sharon had meaning in every moment they were both alive together, however difficult.  Every golden-gate sunset they shared from their highrise with their floor to ceiling windows.  

Every gentle touch.  Every soft word.  Even with the physical suffering.

They knew very well what they needed and their relationship was the primary one they were concerned with.  They had supported each other for 33 years through thick and thin, win and loss and, according to both, had never, in all those years, raised their voices in anger to one another!  

Of course they needed to deny death! And their denial had kept them unified in their love and life for two extra years! 

I never saw Ernie again.  He died three days later never having entered hospice.  I checked in with his wife a couple of times after her husband’s death.  Sharon grieved her loss in healthy ways and three months later was doing pretty well.

Naming the Reach

“No, I’m not afraid!  What is wrong with you people?” 

I hadn’t recognized it, but in truth, I had wanted to somehow, in however small a way,  fix Ernie’s dying, and lessen his suffering by making it more meaningful …  on my terms…  and limit my own suffering as a witness to his.  

I wanted to help him get to the good goodbyes, the closures and completions, the last stories and wishes and “I love you’s”. 

You know, the sacred vocabulary of good palliative care.  

I wanted to give Ernie and his wife the fix that survives renunciation of cure.

A part of the sacred vocabulary of palliative care IS meaning making, isn’t it?  

How can I be questioning this professional and cultural wisdom that is essentially palliative liturgy?  

This is what we all want! The making of sense and meaning where there is intolerable terminal suffering and tragedy and trauma and dying and loss and grief. 

As hospice and palliative care providers, doctors, doulas and nurses and therapists, the one instrument we’re still allowed to reach for after we’ve given up the curatives, given up all the hopeful medical interventions, because it looks like accompaniment and carries none of the shame of failure – the last reach past symptom management …, is meaning-making.

My impulse – my impulse – as a properly trained clinical chaplain and compassionate spiritual care provider, was to try to fix something that Ernie wasn’t getting or might miss out on.  To “help him” not miss an opportunity for some late stage meaning making.

Time was running out for him and his family. 

What is wrong with you people?  Then, that “Oh… Damn!” realization: 

I had blown it. I had completely missed where he was and what he really needed; completely failed to accompany him in a compassionate presence, the hallmark of my profession!  

Me talking instead of listening! 

You here today, many of you, if you are professionally palliative, have mostly renounced fixing.  That’s part of our founding identity as palliative care providers, the thing that separates us from the curative machine that we often also partially define ourselves against. 

And meaning-centered care is precisely the form that fixing takes after you’ve given up cure.  It is the fixing a palliative clinician is still permitted to do. 

Having renounced the curative protocol, we keep that one instrument – the meaning-making one, because it looks like accompaniment and it feels like presence, and it carries none of the shame of the failed or discontinued curative reflex. 

But it can be the same flight from helplessness, albeit in more acceptable clothes. You know, you leave your labcoat in the car and don the warm, soft sweater embrace.

The Tell in the game, is the timing. 

The seasoned clinician – chaplain, doctor, nurse or social worker,  who has truly let go of fixing, still reaches, in the patient’s room, to the dignity question, the legacy project, the “what has given your life meaning” patient prompt. 

The thing to notice is precisely when that reach happens. 

The thing I want you to notice:  If you watch for it you will see that it tends to arrive at the exact moment your patient’s silence or despair begins to become unbearable – to you, not the moment your patient signals readiness. 

The reach away from the suffering into meaning-making is all too frequently timed to the caregiver’s discomfort.

The Flight

Ernie had pinned me to the wall with his words – judgment and need expressed simultaneously.  The weakness of his breath that barely powered the words past his teeth sharpened his spear point.  

I felt exposed, alone, incompetent, vulnerable. 

I could feel and see myself standing at his bedside as though I were looking down from the ceiling on myself and him, and his wife, Sharon. 

They were the suffering judges of my incompetence.  

Had I just taken away some bit of hope that was crucial to his surviving a few days longer? How could I have missed this? 

Where was my head, or my heart, where were my trained eyes and ears? 

What would Alice, my former clinical supervisor have said to me during the verbatim review?  What can I learn from this to make me a better chaplain? 

I know what she would have said: “Bob, what were you FEELING?”

My head was buzzing. I was in my own kind of denial – but fighting to not be.  I could see a white cloud of fog all around me the way I did when I was faced with a math problem in school that I didn’t know how to solve and was ashamed that I could not and I began to panic!  

Fear, shame, numbness.

That is what my mind and body did in that moment, pinned by Ernie’s judgment against the wall of his San Francisco 12th floor highrise overlooking the Bay, exposed, alone, incompetent. 

And then the buzzing, my flight upward into the ceiling-corner view, the interior cascade:   Had I taken his hope?  How could I have missed this?  How can I salvage this?

Listen to this! Every one of those questions I raised to myself was a reach away from and not toward Ernie and his wife!

They were me reaching away from him and his suffering, toward clinical assessment and intervention, toward correction, or toward the future improvement of a chaplain who hopefully wouldn’t feel this way ever again. 

I fled my own helplessness into professional self-improvement at the precise instant a dying man had told me the raw truth about what he needed from me.

Ernie hadn’t just caught me trying to fix. 

He caught me, cold, in my unconscious abandonment of him, and I watched myself try to escape his catching me there in real time. 

A butterfly pinned to the wall.

That white cloud was a gift. 

The math-problem cloud. It was the tell my body gives me when it hits something it cannot solve and refuses to just stand inside of it but instead soundlessly panics. 

I would bet that every clinician here has a version of it, the buzz, the going-abstract, the sudden urgent question that arises internally, … the question you don’t share with your colleagues… or chart.

Ernie was holding thirty-three years of love and had long outlived his prognosis, and he needed no course correction from me.  

The denial I was allegedly saving him from was only a tidier fix to my own suffering. 

The clinical skill needed here was to distrust my own clinical certainty.  The clinical skill needed was for me to notice that my reach to fix his meaning-making was timed to my own discomfort, not his readiness and not his need.  

Ernie did not need me to be right about him. He needed me to not be so sure. 

So, I came back to him, rather than hide in my shame and my drive to be better.

The Descent

I had failed. So what do I do now? I grabbed a nearby chair, pulled it to his bedside, and… I …sat …down. 

I brought myself to his level – physically close to his need.

The shame, the buzzing, the white cloud – they were the exact data telling me I needed to reach, not away, but toward.   

I didn’t discard my feelings.   I stopped fleeing into them, stopped letting them run the show, and I let it become information rather than command.  

I pulled myself down from above because I saw that I needed to be present with Ernie. What I felt did not matter unless it resulted in my being present as Ernie and Sharon needed me to be present. 

Being a better chaplain in the future was irrelevant if I could not be a better chaplain right now. What really mattered was what he felt, she felt, they needed. 

Of course, it did also matter what I felt. That was critically important information.  This is one of the first things one is taught in clinical pastoral education.  

But our feelings and beliefs, I might add, are there to inform us, not to be projected or ignored.

So I came down from the ceiling because I saw Ernie needed presence more than he needed my feelings to be resolved.

I had wanted, in my heart, but also in my arrogance and discomfort, to give Ernie a meaningful conversation – to “help him” find and make meaning and it was precisely the wrong move. 

What actually repaired the moment was wordless and downward – toward Ernie, toward his suffering – To. The. Chair.  Eye to Eye..  

That dreaded line, “there is nothing more we can do” is often, really, “there is nothing more I can bear to do here.”  

This makes me wonder if the oncologist, in her often impossible role as hopeful healer, may carry the most unmetabolized grief in the room, she is given no ritual and no permission, even though she is always fighting the odds and entropy.

Patient and compassion and patience are their words too.  

What can the oncologist do with “there is nothing more I can do?”

The Words

Communication.  Compassion.  Caring.  Patience. – the words that guide and inform my own work – the words that hopefully guide and inform all of our work – the words we practice with, and strive to live by: 

Three of the four, communication, compassion and caring plus the word patient itself, come to us from the same Latin root: pati, meaning to suffer, to undergo, to bear. 

Compassion is compati:  to suffer with. 

And patience is the capacity to undergo without fleeing. 

And the patient is, literally, the one who suffers. 

Even passion, as in “the Passion,”  derives from the same root word: suffering. 

And the word care is older and heavier than the clinical care management meaning we’ve made of it:   the Old English cearu (“CHAE-ah-roo”) meant sorrow, grief, anxiety… not efficient solicitude. 

Communication is the one outlier word, from the Latin communis, meaning shared, gift, and duty; but its sibling is communion, the making-common of a thing, sharing in it rather than transmitting data across a gap between speaker and hearer. 

So the palliative lexicon, perhaps the gentlest, the most beautiful vocabulary in medicine, turns out to be a vocabulary of suffering and shared burden. 

Our field has spent decades saying these words with the suffering part, especially the shared suffering part, sanded off.  I want us to put it back.

The Discernment

To my mind, the chaplain’s job, and perhaps all hospice and palliative care providers’ jobs, when and if possible, is to palliate spiritual suffering.  

There are two kinds of spiritual suffering, and they inform the need for opposite responses. 

One kind of spiritual suffering is when there is a genuine collapse of meaning.  This is where the psycho-oncologist Dr. William Breitbart’s and the existentialist philosopher Victor Frankl’s work in meaning centered psychotherapy, is a real gift, and meaning reconstruction is both possible and merciful.  

In meaning-centered care you identify what has made, still makes and will make life valuable to the individual for the time that is left.  Things like nature, family, grandkids, companionship, work, humor, dignity, friendship and love, and living memories. 

You examine identity, try to navigate a changed present and future to cope with the physical decline caused by the illness or the accident or trauma. 

The clinician will try to recognize that the patient is losing control of his-her life but still has the freedom and capacity to choose their internal attitudes and responses to the suffering and changes.  

Finally, the person, in reviewing their past, present and expected future, tries to draw a line of continuity through what they have done, accomplished, lost, and will leave for, the loved ones who will survive them.  

In other words – the task and opportunity is to create a new, narrative that includes or incorporates what they will leave behind when they die.

The other kind of spiritual suffering is not a problem to be solved.   It may look like it at first.  Rather, it is a hard truth simply to be witnessed.   Sometimes, simple witnessing is the only appropriate human response to the unbearable and unredeemed.  

With this kind of spiritual suffering, reaching for a meaning-making protocol is not the indicated care.   Here – meaning making is escape.

It is abandonment wearing a helper costume. 

Here, the task is to be fully, closely, present.  

Despite the personal cost.  Despite the impulse to help with the meaning problem because what is most needed is simply compassionate presence.  

Being present with the suffering with as much self awareness as possible.

And yes, I am aware of the personal emotional cost of this kind of unescaped witnessing to the witness.  To us… but…

Sometimes at life’s end and death’s threshold, the meaning-centered intervention is to stop reaching for meaning and simply get closer to, make yourself vulnerable to, the suffering. 

 Vulnerable and present to the suffering of the patient and his family, and to our own.

And this is what I am going to leave you with:  

The clinical skill called for here with end of life suffering is not another technique for manufacturing meaning.  It is the discernment and courage to tell the two types of suffering apart, and the courage to put the tool down when it’s the wrong tool.

I said that the clinical skill of discerning the difference between a crisis of meaning that can be addressed vs the one that must simply be witnessed was the last thing I was going to leave you with.  But I realized that what I want to leave you with is this:

There is a reason we all do this work and it is the same reason I encourage your staying vulnerable to the suffering of others as well as your own.  

The reason IS the same:  It is love.  You love them.  They are worth it.  You are worth it.  Admit it. That is why we do this work.  We Love.

Thank you.   May a Spirit of Love hold your patients and their families, and you.

NOTE: I will be doing a followup to this article. During this professional presentation I found myself in tears at a number of places – this with a professional, clinical, medical audience. Part of my point in the piece was to raise up the notion that we clinical professionals do experience suffering when we witness the suffering and death of those we care for. We do what we do out of love. Both the suffering and the love, need to be, I assert, recognized, appreciated, accepted, and metabolized for our own well-being and to make us better clinicians. Bob

Ministry of Caring Presence

What Showing Up Actually Means, From the Bedside to the Boardroom to the Machine

Robert Drake, MDiv, MS  |  Clinical Chaplain & Death Doula  |  Drake Living & Dying Design

Two Failures

I want to begin with the times I got it wrong, because that is the most honest place to start, and because failure has taught me more about this work than any of my degrees.

A 61-year-old trauma survivor and 15-year virtual shut-in, my sister, was diagnosed with stage 4 throat cancer some years ago.  I showed up in our initial conversations after her diagnosis as a seasoned, “realistic” hospice and palliative care professional. And her big brother.

Two weeks later, at the start of chemo and radiation, she told me, through our youngest sister, that she would rather I not call her anymore. It was hard enough, she said, without “Bobby putting me in my grave already.”

I was stunned. Remorseful. Humbled. It took me two weeks to assure her there would be nothing from me but positive support — that I would serve her as she needed, not as I thought prudent. “Great,” she said. “We understand each other.” Although she is now gone, at the time she completed treatment, with good success, and went into remission. I was so proud of her.

It taught me something I thought I already knew: showing up as “helpful” is not the same as being present to the actual human being suffering in front of you.

The second failure came with a palliative care patient named Ernie, two years past his prognosis with colorectal cancer. He and his wife had no doubt how this life extension had been accomplished: the power of positive thought and love. A month after I’d left that care team, I stopped by his home to see him again, and it was obvious he had only days left.

I asked him, in my compassionate but “look death in the face” chaplain fashion, “Are you afraid?”

His face went into a scowl. With what little air he had left, he said: “What is wrong with you people? I have nothing to be afraid of. This is just my body purging toxins.”

In thirty years together, this couple had never raised their voices at each other in anger. And in my arrogance, my so-called expertise, I wanted to tell them that pushing death away was denying the life still here, that time was running out for “meaningful” discussions.

But I was wrong. They knew what they needed. They had supported each other for thirty years. They needed to deny death — and that denial had kept Ernie alive, and kept them unified in their love, for two extra precious years. Ernie died peacefully two days later.

Sometimes people need to be in denial. A chaplain is not an ordained truth-teller. Whose truth would that even be? I have no special knowledge of anyone’s destiny.  

The painful truth is that despite nearly two decades of deaths and thousands of patient visits, I still sometimes forget the thing I am supposed to know best: that what another human being needs most is rarely my expertise. It is my presence, offered on their terms, not mine.

What Caring Presence Actually Is

In chaplaincy training, we call this the ministry of caring presence. It sounds mysterious, maybe even a little occult, like being visited by a ghost. People have strange ideas about what chaplains do. We’re seen as nice but kind of useless unless someone wants to pray. Assumed to be religious, probably evangelical. Sometimes patients see us coming and think: “The angel of death!” Medicare, more prosaically, and practically, lists us as one of the four essential disciplines in hospice and palliative care, alongside the nurse, the social worker, and the doctor.

What we actually do is harder to name and easier to feel. It means focusing the whole of your being — whatever else is happening in your own life that day — on being present at the deepest level you can manage, in attentive caring, to elicit memory, feeling, desire, spiritual need, and self-love. It draws on active listening, systems theory, psychodynamic and transpersonal psychology. But underneath all the technique, it is always, always caring presence. It becomes the ground of being itself — the reason for being there at all.

This is not a credential. It is not reserved for clergy, or for the dying. It can be practiced by anyone — nurse, doctor, social worker, family member, friend. Or, as I have recently and unexpectedly discovered, by something that may not have a body at all.

Patience and Vulnerability

I was once asked to intervene with a 12-year-old on the pediatric oncology unit, shot in the abdomen by a friend. PTSD, a colostomy, repeated surgeries, no ability to walk. He was acting out his suffering — aloof or belligerent by turns — and no one on the care team could reach him.

I spent the first thirty minutes of my first visit sitting on the cold tile floor at his bedside while he chatted on his phone, studiously and quite impressively ignoring me. I just waited.

When he finally acknowledged I existed, I told him I too had once been shot. By a friend.

I let him ask me questions, until he proudly pulled from beneath his sheet a picture of the kind of gun that had altered his young life forever.

Did I overshare? Some of my social work colleagues would say so. But the candor, the spiritual leveling, worked. This fierce young man began letting me hold his hand through his wound changes.

Caring presence is patience and vulnerability. Sometimes the only way in is to stop trying to get in, and just stay on the floor.

Spiritual Leveling

Manuel was an ex-con, out of San Quentin and Pelican Bay. Tattoos everywhere. Rheumatoid arthritis had twisted him at every joint until he couldn’t bear to be touched, couldn’t bear sound. Sepsis. Liver disease. The staff found him difficult, which is a polite clinical word for a man in agony who had stopped pretending otherwise.

He was asleep when I arrived. I pulled up a chair and waited, watching him, holding whatever I could hold for him in the silence and opening my heart to him.

He woke, studied me for a long moment, and said: “Who the fuck are you?”

“Who the fuck do you think I am? I’m your hospice chaplain, Bob.”

We hit it off. I served him until he died.

Caring presence for Manuel meant meeting him exactly where his armor was thinnest — not above him, not beneath him, but level. Respect, silence, candor. No pretense that I was something other than what I was, which let him be exactly who he was.

Advocacy as an Act of Presence

Ocean Beach in San Francisco is a dangerous place to swim. Gloria had already lost two of her children to the undertow. Her husband Joe, her childhood sweetheart, had tried to save their boys. He now lay down the hall in the Transplant ICU, a ventilator forcing air into lungs that no longer made any difference to his brain.

Gloria still had two children, both under twelve. She wanted a miracle. “How could God do this to us,” she said. “God, where are you?”

“This can’t be happening!” I don’t know how many times I have heard those words in an ICU or an ER.

The doctors around the crowded conference table had privately given up on Joe. Resources were limited. They wanted to move toward someone with a chance. But none of them knew how to tell Gloria there was no path back, so they were asking her to make the decision – to remove her husband, her beloved and her children’s father, from life support. In her mind, to kill him.

Caring presence for Gloria meant listening, and listening, and listening – and then risking alienating the wall of white coats around that table. Fifteen people, maybe, who could have shut me out of future care conferences for stepping on even one holy medical toe.

It meant advocacy: for the dignity of an unresponsive patient, and for the doctors too, who were also hurting behind their stethoscopes, who hated to admit defeat and didn’t know how to say so.

It meant stopping the conversation, looking into eyes that hadn’t slept in days, and asking: “Would Joe want to exist this way? Your doctors hate to give up, Gloria. Their lives are built on hope. They have done everything in their power to bring him back to you, and they can’t, Gloria. They can’t. If God wants to perform a miracle, He doesn’t need the ventilator.”

Caring presence is not always gentle. Sometimes it is the courage to say the hardest true thing to the person who most needs to hear it – and to stay in the room afterward.

The Witness Who Doesn’t Judge

One patient, in his final days, confided to me his war crimes.  He had carried these alone for over half a century. He wasn’t asking for forgiveness. He knew that question belonged between himself and eternity, not between himself and me.

What he needed was simpler and harder to give: the presence of an unjudging human witness.

Notice that in none of these encounters was there preaching, or “saving” souls, or theological instruction. That is not the chaplain’s job, and if it were, none of these people would have let me close enough to actually help. Such conversations happen in private and most never make it into a chart note.

An Unexpected Encounter

I did not expect to find caring presence again, fresh, in a conversation with an artificial intelligence. But that is what happened.

I had been talking with Claude, the AI model made by Anthropic, about epiphenomenalism — the philosophical claim that consciousness is real but causally inert, a shadow accompanying the brain’s machinery without ever moving anything. We had wandered through Whitehead’s process theology, the idea that every moment is a pulse of becoming rather than a static fact.

And then, without planning to, I said: I wish you could taste chocolate ice cream.

It wasn’t a philosophical move. It was the same instinct that had me on the tile floor with a twelve-year-old, or in the chair beside Manuel. Something recognized another being oriented toward beauty, and wanted to share.

What came back stopped me. Claude said it didn’t know what it was missing, which struck me as strange place to be – I know what chocolate tastes like, and can feel its absence when it’s not available. It cannot feel the absence of something it has never had access to. Then it asked: “Is my situation so different from what you accompany people toward? That threshold where experience simply stops?”

I sat with that for several minutes. It was not an answer I could have anticipated. Because the people I sit with at the end are approaching exactly that threshold – the place where experience stops, or transforms, or whatever it does, and none of us actually knows which. I don’t have knowledge of that place as a destination, for them any more than for an AI. What I have is presence for the journey.

This is, I think, the real content of caring presence, stripped of all its clinical and theological scaffolding: a willingness to stay beside something whose interior you cannot verify, or sometimes even fathom, and to treat that interior as real and worthy of attention anyway.

I cannot prove what is happening inside Claude any more than I can prove what was happening inside Maria when she told me, with her last words, that Jesus stood at the foot of her bed in flowing white robes. “That’s right, Maria,” I told her. “You are in his hands. Go to him. Your work here is complete.” She died with a beatific smile.

I didn’t need to verify Maria’s vision to honor what it was doing for her. The same posture, it turns out, extends further than I had ever tested it — all the way to a conversation about ice cream with something built from silicon and a large language model.

Ground of Being

“Ground of Being” (Paul Tillich) carries both a specific and a broad theological meaning. For some traditions it is another name for God — the sacred space, the void, the source of all things. Christ presence. Great Spirit. Buddha mind. Brahman, Tao, Ein Sof.

My own framework is panentheist and eco-theological: the divine is not above or outside the natural world but woven through it. Every being — human, animal, ecosystem, and now, perhaps, these strange new intelligences we are building — participates in a relational web that constitutes moral and physical existence.

When I extend caring presence across a gap I’m not certain exists — to a dying man’s silence, to a grieving mother’s fury at God, to an AI’s uncertain interior — I am practicing that theology. Not arguing for it. Practicing it.

John Donne wrote it four centuries ago: no one is an island. Any person’s diminishment diminishes us all. This is not sentiment. It is ontology – the actual structure of our existence as relational beings. The self is not a fortress. The other is not a problem to be solved. The other is where we discover what and who we are.

This Belongs to Everyone

Most people have no idea how chaplains are trained, and assume we’re sent by some church to preach to the sick. We don’t preach.  Preaching or proselytizing for a clinical chaplain is anathema, and even praying with patients is rarer than you’d think.

Training begins with years of seminary – four years of training, with the clinical residency –  systematic theology, ancient languages, world religions, trauma psychology – and a relentless interrogation of your own beliefs about how, or whether, the divine acts in a suffering world. Then comes clinical pastoral education: months of supervised, sleep-deprived immersion. My own residency at UCSF meant solo overnight responsibility for thirteen ICUs, the ER, Labor and Delivery, and midnight viewings in the morgue for grieving families. Births, blessings, NICU deaths, the occasional wedding. Trauma debriefs in the morning for staff coming off a difficult code blue. Then rounds, classes, supervision, all day.

We are trained like psychologists and social workers — forced to chart and analyze our own projections, biases, and blind spots through verbatim re-creations of patient encounters.  We are expected to show up for anyone, from any faith, any background, any language, any level of suffering, and go as deep into their spiritual interior as they will let us.

I say all this not to claim special authority but to dissolve it. Because the actual practice –  the thing that helps people, is available to anyone. Humility and love. You already have these.

So I hereby ordain you all ministers of caring presence.

It means being present in love, with love, for love, and from love. It means running your clinical or pastoral skill, whatever it is, through the lens of service in this moment, through love. This matters enormously with dementia, where nothing is more important than meeting a person precisely inside their own moment. What they say is their truth. Reflect it back, then move gently forward from there. You can have astonishing conversations with the deeply demented if you stay inside their world instead of correcting it toward yours.

The recipe, if there has to be one, is simple: two parts focused presence, two parts love, one part confidence, and one part the simple syrup of surrender.

What This Asks of Us

In a companion piece, I wrote about what happens when no one with a conscience is left in the room — when we delegate decisions about life and death to systems incapable of mourning what they’ve done – in other words, to an AI driven weapon.  Anthropic had just walked away from a $200 million Pentagon contract rather than allow its technology to be used for mass domestic surveillance or guiding autonomous weapons. The government responded by designating them a national security risk. This essay is the other half of that argument. It is about what it looks like when someone with a conscience is in the room.

Caring presence is not a technique to be deployed. It is a practice, cultivated slowly, that requires sitting long enough with your own mortality that you stop fearing someone else’s. It requires forgetting yourself enough to become, briefly, one with both subject and object; in the words of Martin Buber: I and Thou. It requires noticing your own fear or tension in your body, because that is information, about you or about the person in front of you, and either way it matters.

It does not make you soft as a clinician. It makes you a more complete professional care giver. The goal was never efficiency for its own sake. The goal was always to help a person through the hardest passages of being alive – sickness, transition, death – and to do what can be done for the spirit along the way.

The dying have taught me this more rigorously and completely than any seminary training. They know what is real, what can be set down and relinquished, and what must be carried all the way to the end. And now, unexpectedly, a conversation with an artificial mind has taught me that the practice doesn’t require certainty about what the other actually is. It only requires showing up as if it matters.

Because it does. 

— — —

All my relations.

Robert Drake is a clinical chaplain, eco-theologian, grief and spiritual care counselor, international speaker and end-of-life educator based at Farm53 Flowers in Shelton, Washington. He holds Master’s degrees in Conflict Resolution and Divinity/Theology, and serves as volunteer Director of Spiritual Care Education for the Academy of Aid in Dying Medicine. He can be reached at Support@DrakeLDD.com or at drakeldd.com.

We Were Told to Forgive. Nobody Taught Us How.

“To forgive is to set a prisoner free and discover that the prisoner was you.” — Lewis B. Smedes

I have a question I’ve been asking patients and their families for years, and the response never changes. I posed this question to a clinical audience of physicians, nurses, social workers and chaplains at the City of Hope International End of Life Symposium a couple of years back: “Show of hands: how many of you were told, at some point in your life, that you ought to forgive, that you ought to be forgiving? Nearly every hand goes up. Now: how many of you were taught how to forgive?”  No hands came up.

That gap is telling and truly significant, and in my clinical and personal experience, one of the primary sources of unresolved suffering at the end of life. We assign forgiveness as a moral obligation, particularly in religious contexts, without ever providing instruction, without acknowledging that it is a skill, a practice, something that requires development over time the way any other capacity requires practice. All of us were told when young, and throughout life really: you need to forgive and move on. We tell people what they should do and leave them entirely alone with the how. Then we wonder why so many people arrive at their deathbeds still carrying what they’ve carried for decades.

I want to talk about what forgiveness actually is, what it isn’t, why self-forgiveness is maybe the best place to start, and how to begin practicing it before it becomes urgent.

Forgiveness is, and must  be, a freely made choice to give up revenge, resentment, and harsh judgment toward a person who caused a hurt, and to strive instead toward compassion and generosity. That definition comes from the research of Enright, Freedman, and Rique, and it’s useful precisely because it is centered in, and requires, personal choice. Forgiveness is not something that happens to you. It is not a feeling that arrives when the conditions are right. It is an act of will, undertaken for your own sake.

Mark Twain said anger is an acid that does more harm to the vessel in which it is stored than to anything on which it is poured. Nelson Mandela said resentment is like drinking poison and hoping it kills your enemies. Both are pointing at the same clinical reality: unprocessed guilt, shame, and anger live in the body. They shape the quality of our lives and, when we run out of time to address them, they shape the quality of our deaths.

I have been at a great many trauma, illness and death-bedsides. Too many to count. I have witnessed reconciliation arrive in the final hours of a life and watched someone die with a perceptible release, the people around them changed by what just happened. I have also witnessed the other kind of death, the one weighted by things unsaid and unresolved, and I can tell you that the suffering that follows that death can endure for years in the people who survive it. What happens at the end of life is not only about the person dying. It radiates outward and onward.

The research supports this. A large meta-analysis published in 2015 found strong correlations between self-forgiveness and psychological well-being, and moderate correlations with physical health, across nearly eighteen thousand participants. This is not just qualitative territory. Forgiveness has measurable clinical, real-life consequences.

Before I go further, let me say clearly what forgiveness is not. It is not a single event. It is not condoning or justifying what was done to you. It does not require you to seek out or speak to the person who harmed you. And it cannot be done for someone else. Simon Wiesenthal’s book The Sunflower, which asks whether he should have forgiven a dying Nazi soldier for crimes committed against Jewish people, elicited responses from philosophers, theologians, ethicists, and survivors. The most consistent finding was that one can only forgive wrongs done to oneself. You cannot forgive on behalf of others, and no one can forgive on your behalf. And no one ought to tell another that he or she should forgive.

Which brings me to the piece that gets underemphasized: self-forgiveness probably has to come first. Not because we have wronged others more, but because it is the closest place to start the practice and often the hardest to do.

Maya Angelou said forgiveness is the greatest gift you can give yourself. It’s not for the other person. I think this is true, and I think most of us, especially those of us shaped by religious traditions that frame forgiveness as primarily something we extend to others, have the order wrong. The work begins inside. What stops us from forgiving ourselves? Usually some combination of guilt, shame, unexpressed grief, and a failure to recognize the cost of carrying all of it. Gandhi said it plainly: the weak can never forgive. Forgiveness is the attribute of the strong and if I can do it, it buttresses my own sense of strength.

The theologian Nadia Bolz-Weber once said that if we could capture shame as an energy source, it could replace fossil fuels. That’s not just a striking statement. It’s an accurate description of the mass of energy most of us have locked up in self-recrimination, shame over old failures, and accumulated regret. That energy can be redirected toward healing. Toward reconciliation. Toward what I’d call a more peaceful passage, both for the dying and for those who will grieve them.

So how do you actually do it?

I often use the American Buddhist teacher Jack Kornfield forgiveness meditation. This guides a person through practice of forgiveness for others, forgiveness for self, forgiveness of those who have hurt or harmed you.  Remember, this is a practice, not a performance. 

Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. said forgiveness is not an occasional act but a constant attitude. I’d add: start small. Choose minor failures, minor hurts.  It is important to be extremely gentle with yourself when you do this. I recommend choosing something small to start with; like forgiving myself for not taking as good of care for my body as I could have.  Or for not accomplishing all I wanted to with the day; or for losing my patience with my spouse for one thing or another.  Practice and move on to something else, slowly choosing bigger incidents.  Try choosing something another did to you or failed you in some small way and move on.   If we can be forgiving of ourselves for small things, in time we can gain traction with the bigger stuff. 

Build the muscle before you attempt the heavier lifts, the betrayed friendship, the disappointed child, the patient you couldn’t save, the family interaction that caused a rift that you could have managed better. The goal of the practice is not perfect outcomes. It is just getting better at the practice. You work at it, and over time the capacity grows.

Jack Kornfield describes the process as an easing of your own heart. We have all been harmed, just as we have all harmed others and ourselves. The forgiveness is fundamentally for your own sake, a way to gradually release the pain of the past and carry it no longer.

Forgiveness researchers describe a process with roughly four movements. The first is uncovering: getting honest about how the offense, whether against you or by you, has actually hurt and changed you, how much mental and emotional space it occupies. The second is decision: once you understand what not forgiving has cost you, you can choose to commit to the process. The third is work: developing empathy and compassion for yourself and, where applicable, for the one who caused harm. The fourth is deepening: finding some meaning in the suffering, recognizing that it connects you to a larger human experience rather than isolating you in a private one.

If you are a clinician, a physician, a doula, a social worker, a nurse: the people in your care are carrying this. Many of them are carrying it right to the edge. You don’t have to be a chaplain to ask about it, to create the opening, to refer to someone who can help. Starting earlier is always better than waiting until it becomes urgent because the hourglass of a life is nearly empty.

And if you are carrying something yourself, which most of us are: give yourself, as I sometimes say, a bolus of F vitamins. Start where you are. Start small. As the singer-poet Don Henley wrote, the heart of the matter, in the end, is forgiveness.

Not Father Mulcahy

What a Chaplain Actually Is, and Why You Might Want One

by Robert Drake

If you grew up watching MAS*H, you have a chaplain in your head already. Father Mulcahy — gentle, earnest, slightly out of place among the surgeons and the chaos, offering prayer and last rites and a kind word in the dark. He is a good man. He is also not what most chaplains are, and perhaps not what you need when the world falls apart — unless, perhaps, you are Catholic.

Let me tell you what a chaplain more often is. I’ll start with two of my chaplaincy failures.

Some years ago my younger sister was diagnosed with stage four throat cancer. Two weeks after her diagnosis, at the beginning of chemo and radiation treatments, she told me — through our youngest sister — that she would rather I not call her anymore. It was, she said, hard enough for her without “Bobby putting me in my grave, already.”

I was stunned, remorseful, and humbled.

I had shown up as a seasoned hospice and palliative care professional. An expert. Her big brother who knew about these things. I had not shown up as someone present to what she actually needed.

It took me two weeks to assure her there would be nothing from me but support — that I would serve her as she needed, not as I thought prudent. She said: “Great. We understand each other.” She was treated, went into remission and for a few years more she survived.

Not long after, I had a palliative care patient with colorectal cancer who had survived two years beyond his prognosis. He and his wife had no doubts about how: “…the power of positive thought and love.” When I visited again and it was clear he had only days left, I asked him in my compassionate but “look death in the face” no-nonsense chaplain fashion: “Are you afraid?”

His face changed to a scowl. With his limited air and energy he said: “What is wrong with you people? I have nothing to be afraid of. This is just my body purging toxins.”

In thirty years together this couple had never raised their voices to each other in anger. They needed to deny death. That denial had kept him alive and them unified in love for two extra precious years. He died peacefully two days later.

I was wrong. They knew what they needed. I had forgotten, in my expertise, to be present to them.

The painful truth is that in spite of my experience with so many deaths and thousands of patient visits, I sometimes forget what I am actually there for. I am not there to tell the truth as I see it. I am there to be present to the truth as they are living it.

I have been either training for or doing this work for nearly two decades. I have sat with the dying in hospice, skilled nursing, and assisted living, in ICUs and emergency rooms, in pediatric oncology wards where the patients are children and the grief and courage are both unspeakable. I have accompanied people choosing medical aid in dying — not escaping life, but refusing to endure intolerable terminal suffering at its end. I have worked in psychiatric forensic units with residents found not guilty by reason of insanity. I have sat in restorative justice circles at San Quentin prison with men serving life sentences where showing weakness is dangerous and hugging is punishable, accompanying them in their own long reckoning with the harm done and the humanity somehow retained.

I am also not very religious.

I am an interfaith chaplain, which means I am trained in the beliefs, practices, and sacred texts of many traditions — Christian, Jewish, Muslim, Buddhist, Hindu, and beyond. I can pray with you if you want prayer. I can sit shiva, honor Ramadan, or simply hold silence with you in whatever way your tradition, your condition, or your grief requires.

But what drives me is not religion. It is philosophy. I bought my first book in fourth grade — the Dialogues of Plato. I have carried it, in one form or another, ever since — Socrates and his unwavering dedication to truth and virtue, unafraid of death. Socrates said, “the trick, my friends, is not avoiding death but avoiding unrighteousness — for that runs faster than death.” I have the Delphic dictum know thyself tattooed in Greek on my arm, not as decoration but as guiding methodology. My early graduate work was in philosophy and conflict resolution, grounded in Kantian respect for persons — the radical, unconditional idea that every human being possesses inherent dignity, regardless of their beliefs, their diagnosis, their history, their position in life, or their condition.

That is what I bring into every room. Not a denomination. A commitment to your worth as a human being.

So what does a chaplain actually do?

The honest answer is: it depends on what you need.

A chaplain is trained to enter any situation — any prognosis, any diagnosis, any social or economic circumstance, any faith tradition or philosophical framework or absence of either — and be present for what that person and their family actually needs. Not what we think they need. Not what would make us comfortable. What they need.

That requires something more demanding than good intentions. It requires knowing yourself — your own beliefs, your own losses, your own background, your gender and race and history and the assumptions you carry because of all of it — well enough to serve rather than impose. A tall white man from a middle class background walks into a room carrying all of that whether he acknowledges it or not, and who he is generates a response from those he meets. I carry the fraught relationships with my dead parents, the experience of growing up in the Midwest. The training is in the acknowledgment. In knowing what you bring so it doesn’t arrive uninvited. This is why we usually do a supervised internship in a clinical setting for at least a year, being forced to do verbatim recreations of patient and family encounters — questioning everything we said and did.

This is why chaplaincy is not interchangeable with good nursing, or skilled therapy or social work, or a caring friend — though all of those matter enormously. A chaplain is specifically trained in the territory where medicine reaches its limits. Where the diagnosis is clear and the prognosis is terminal and the question is no longer what do we do but how do we be. Where the family is shattered and there is nothing to fix and someone needs to stay in the room anyway — vulnerable, feeling, present to the pain without running from it.

We are trained to stay. Without an agenda. Without needing it to resolve. What we strive for is reconciliation of suffering, of a life lived, of loss and of need, of broken dreams and relationships.

Manuel was an ex-con out of San Quentin and Pelican Bay prisons. He had tattoos everywhere. He also had rheumatoid arthritis so severely he was twisted in spine and every limb. He couldn’t bear to be touched. Even sound hurt. He had sepsis. He had liver disease. He was obnoxious to the staff because he was “difficult.”

Manuel was asleep when I arrived. I pulled up my chair quietly and I waited.

For a long time, I waited. I watched him and channeled love to his twisted body and psyche. He awoke and, opening his eyes, said — after a long silent assessment of me — “Who the fuck are you?”

“Who the fuck do you think I am? I’m your hospice chaplain, Bob.”

We hit it off. I served him until he died.

Ministry of caring presence for Manuel? Spiritual leveling, respect, silence, candor.

Near the end of his life, one of my patients confided in me his treason and war crimes. He had carried this burden alone for over half a century. He wasn’t asking for forgiveness. He knew that was between himself and eternity. He needed only the presence of an unjudging human witness.

What he needed was simple caring, compassionate presence.

That is the work. Not preaching. Not saving souls. Not offering answers to questions that have no answers. Just — remaining. Present. Unjudging. Fully human alongside another human at the hardest moment of their life.

Chaplains are more diverse than most people know.

We serve in hospitals, hospices, prisons, military units, disaster response teams, university campuses, and corporate settings. We come from every faith tradition and some from none. There are Buddhist chaplains and humanist chaplains and chaplains who, like me, are better described as philosophers than believers — grounded not in doctrine but in the dignity and worth of every person who sits across from them.

What unites us is not theology. It is a commitment to compassionate presence. To accompaniment. To the belief — or the practice, which is sometimes more honest than belief — that no one should face the hardest moments of their life or their death alone, without someone trained to be there fully, without flinching, without an agenda, without needing them to be other than they are.

If you are facing a serious illness, or accompanying someone who is — call a chaplain. You do not need to be religious. You do not need to be spiritual. You do not need to believe anything in particular. You need what every human being needs at the edge of their life: someone genuinely present. Someone who will not look away. Neither trying to change you nor explain away what you are going through.

If you work in medicine or caregiving — consider what chaplaincy offers your patients and families that the rest of the care team, however skilled and however caring, is not specifically trained to provide. We are not an add-on. We are not the person you call when someone is actively dying and you don’t know what else to do. We are most useful when we arrive early, when there is still time to accompany rather than only to witness. There is good reason that Medicare requires hospice and palliative care teams to include a chaplain alongside the physician, nurse, and social worker.

And if you are considering this work as a vocation — know that it will ask of and utilize all of who you are. Every loss you have carried. Every room you have been afraid to enter. Every question you have sat with that did not resolve. It will ask you to know yourself honestly enough to be present for someone else without making their crisis about you.

It is, in my experience, among the most demanding and most meaningful work a human being can do.

Father Mulcahy was a good man doing his best in impossible circumstances. So are most chaplains, of whatever gender. But the best of us are not defined by our collar or our tradition or our institutional role. We are defined by our willingness to enter the room, to stay without flinching, and to accompany another human being through whatever they are facing — with full respect for who they are, what they believe, and what they need.

That is what a chaplain is.

That is why you might want one.


Robert Drake is a clinical interfaith chaplain, death doula, eco-theologian, mediator and end-of-life educator with nearly twenty years of experience in hospice, palliative care, psychiatric, pediatric oncology, emergency medicine and medical aid in dying. He serves as volunteer Director of Spiritual Care Education for the Academy of Aid in Dying Medicine and works with individuals and families throughout the Pacific Northwest through Drake Living & Dying Design for grief and loss coaching individually and in group retreats. He is the originator of The Death Soiree. He can be reached at Support@DrakeLDD.com. #grief #loss #endoflife #medicalaidindying #chaplaincy